MidJourney V6 vs DALL-E 3: AI-driven graphic design, creators are constantly seeking tools that not only produce visually appealing results but also accurately interpret and implement given prompts.
In this article, I will delve into a face-off between two prominent AI graphic design tools, MidJourney V6 and DALLE-3, specifically focusing on their performance in responding to text prompts.
The comparison is based on the results obtained from nine different print-on-demand scenarios.
Round 1: Cheese the Day Cartoon Style
In the initial round, both MidJourney and DALLE-3 were tasked with creating a cartoon-style image featuring various cheese characters. MidJourney displayed vibrant colors and an artistic vibe, deviating from the specified cartoon style. However, the spelling accuracy was a significant drawback, with words like “carp Brie-um” and “Bri carpet” appearing randomly.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourney-v6-vs-dalle-1-1024x536.webp)
On the other hand, DALLE-3 adhered closely to the prompt, showcasing joyful and playful cheese characters.
The spelling accuracy was commendable, with the phrase “cheese the day” rendered correctly. MidJourney’s aesthetic appeal, DALL-E 3 secured this round with its commitment to the specified parameters and accurate text representation.
Round 2: Quality Gains Koala Flat Design
In round two, the prompt involved creating a 2D flat design featuring a koala lifting a massive dumbbell with the text “quality gains.” Mid Journey presented two contrasting graphics – one adhering to flat design and the other incorporating detailed elements.
While the spelling was accurate, the deviation from the flat design was evident.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourneyv6-vs-dalle-3-2-1024x536.webp)
DALLE-3, on the other hand, crafted a more fitting representation of a koala working out, with the dumbbells looking visually appealing.
A misspelling in the text, DALLE-3’s commitment to the prompt and overall design secured this round, making it a challenging decision for the evaluator.
Round 3: Messy Hair Bun Stylish Girl
In the third round, the complexity increased with a detailed prompt for a 2D flat color drawing of a stylish girl with a messy bun hairstyle, wearing a bandana and sunglasses.
Both MidJourney and DALLE-3 showcased distinct styles, with Mid Journey leaning towards a more detailed and artistic portrayal, while DALLE-3 opted for a simpler, cartoonish approach.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourneyv6-vs-dalle-3-1024x536.webp)
Spelling accuracy favored DALLE-3, with both “mom of a warrior” instances correctly spelled.
MidJourney V6 struggled with text representation, making DALLE-3 the winner of this round due to its adherence to the prompt and superior spelling accuracy.
Round 4: Pizza and Beer Flat 2D Cartoon Graphic
In a simpler prompt for a flat 2D cartoon graphic of a pizza and beer, Mid Journey and DALLE-3 took different approaches. MidJourney’s design, while not entirely cartoonish, exhibited visually appealing aesthetics and accurate spelling.
However, DALLE-3’s cartoon-themed graphic, although more fitting, suffered from spelling inaccuracies in the word “beer.”
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourneyv6-vs-dalle-4-1024x536.webp)
Mid Journey’s deviation from the cartoon style, its correct spelling, and overall design made it the winner of this round, showcasing the importance of a balanced approach between prompt adherence and visual appeal.
Round 5: Colorful Vector Illustration – Wise Owl Wisdom
The fifth round introduced a colorful vector illustration prompt for a comical owl wearing glasses with the text “Wise Owl Wisdom.” Mid Journey embraced a vintage, textured style, while DALLE-3 prioritized vibrant colors and a more contemporary look.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourney-v6-vs-dalle-5-1024x536.webp)
Spelling accuracy favored both tools, with “Wise Owl Wisdom” correctly rendered.
The decision between the vintage appeal of Mid Journey and the colorful vibrancy of DALLE-3 came down to personal preference, making this round a subjective call.
Round 6: Vaporwave-Themed Raccoon Design
In the sixth round, the prompt called for a vaporwave-themed t-shirt design featuring a raccoon wearing sunglasses with the text “I eat trash.” MidJourney showcased intricate details, while DALLE-3 opted for a simpler, more suitable design for print-on-demand.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourney-v6-vs-dalle-6-1024x536.webp)
A spelling error in DALLE-3’s result, its cleaner and more straightforward design earned it the victory in this round. The decision reflected the importance of adaptability and simplicity in creating marketable designs for print-on-demand.
Round 7: Avocado Holding AO Nice Day Sign
The seventh round involved creating a flat vector graphic of an avocado holding a sign with the text “AO nice day.” Both Mid Journey and DALLE-3 presented visually pleasing designs, with Mid Journey’s deviation being the size of the text.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourney-v6-vs-dalle-7-1024x536.webp)
Mid Journey’s unique style, DALLE-3’s more readable text and simplistic design made it the winner of this round, emphasizing the significance of legibility in print on demand graphics.
Round 8: Good Vibes Only Typography Design
Round eight featured a Good Vibes Only typography design with a rough, distressed font. Mid Journey applied the distressed look effectively, while DALLE-3 presented an experimental style that, while cool, compromised text legibility.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourneyv6-vs-dall-e-8-1024x536.webp)
The decision leaned towards Mid Journey due to its cohesive implementation of the distressed font and overall aesthetics. This round highlighted the delicate balance between experimental design and practicality.
Round 9: Vintage Distressed Surfboard Graphic
In the final round, both tools were tasked with creating a vintage distressed graphic design featuring a surfboard with the text “Dad who loves surfing.” Mid Journey’s interpretation included surfboards in the sea within a square frame, while DALLE-3 embraced the vintage sunset design style.
![](https://midjourneyv6.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/midjourney-v6-vs-dalle-9-1024x536.webp)
A minor misspelling in DALLE-3’s result, its more marketable vintage design secured the victory in this round. This emphasized the importance of understanding the market preferences and tailoring designs accordingly.
Conclusion:
In this comprehensive comparison between Mid Journey V6 and DALLE-3, both AI graphic design tools demonstrated their unique strengths and weaknesses. While Mid Journey showcased an ability to generate aesthetically pleasing designs quickly, DALLE-3 excelled in adhering to prompt specifications and creating simpler, more marketable graphics for print on demand.
Ultimately, the winner between MidJourney and DALLE-3 depends on individual preferences and the specific requirements of a design project.
Demi Franco, a BTech in AI from CQUniversity, is a passionate writer focused on AI. She crafts insightful articles and blog posts that make complex AI topics accessible and engaging.